Best Peanut Butter Whiskeys

Last Updated on: 16th April 2024, 07:39 pm

Top Peanut Butter Whiskeys Ranked: From Lackluster to Best-in-Class

Written by: J Highland

Peanut butter whiskey, blending creamy peanut flavors with whiskey’s warmth, has gained popularity, though quality differs among brands.

This guide, created with the assistance of whiskey expert Neil Coleman and customer feedback ranks them, so you find your next favorite.

Choosing the Best Peanut Butter Whiskey

• Skrewball: Remains a top choice for peanut butter whiskey enthusiasts looking for a true peanut butter taste with hints of chocolate and roasted nuts, great on the rocks or in rich, dessert-like cocktails.
• Sheep Dog: Best for those who prefer a subtle peanut butter flavor mixed with caramel and vanilla. Ideal for sweeter cocktails where its gentle peanut butter theme can complement rather than dominate.
• Ram’s Point: Suitable for cocktails like a Coca-Cola mix, offering a strong peanut butter taste with a hint of rubber, which might be less noticeable in mixed drinks.
• SQRRL: A good option for those who enjoy a sweet, syrupy whiskey with a supporting peanut butter note, making it unique in cocktails that can handle or complement its sweetness.
• Skatterbrain: Excels in dessert-themed cocktails due to its vanilla, coffee, and mocha profile, where the light peanut flavor provides a subtle enhancement rather than the main feature.
• P’Nutty: Perfect for those who enjoy a honey-roasted taste with a whiskey warmth, great for sipping neat or on the rocks, thanks to its comforting, sweet profile.
• Bird Dog: Stands out for its robust peanut butter flavor and higher proof, making it ideal for sipping straight or in bold, flavor-forward cocktails.
• Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as a spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.

Quick Look at the Peanut Butter Whiskeys Rankings

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

Whiskey	Price	Proof
Skrewball	$20	70
Bird Dog	$18	80
P’Nutty	$22	70
Skatterbrain	$20	70
SQRRL	$20	70
Ram’s Point	$18	70
Sheep Dog	$17	70

Sheep Dog: A Sweet Treat with a Hint of Nut

• Nose: Caramel, vanilla, peanut butter
• Palate: Corn syrup, caramel, peanut butter
• Finish: Caramel, peanut butter
• Alcohol content: 70 proof (35% ABV)
• How to drink: Rocks

Sheep Dog entices with aromas of caramel and vanilla, followed by a whisper of peanut butter. The taste is surprisingly sweet, with corn syrup and caramel leading the way, while peanut butter plays a supporting role. The finish is short and sweet, echoing the peanut butter theme.

While the peanut butter isn’t the star, Sheep Dog’s sweetness makes it a good option for cocktails, states whiskey expert Neil Coleman.

Ram’s Point: Peanut Butter Punch with a Rubbery Hint

• Nose: Reese’s, alcohol
• Palate: Peanut butter, caramel, rubber
• Finish: Short, caramel, peanut
• Alcohol content: 70 proof (35% ABV)
• How to drink: Rocks

Ram’s Point hits the nose with a powerful Reese’s aroma, hinting at sweetness. A fleeting alcohol note fades fast. The taste explodes with peanut butter, balanced by subtle caramel and vanilla. The finish is short and warming, offering caramel, peanut, but unfortunately, a lingering bitterness.

Despite the peanut butter flavor and a slight rubber presence, Ram’s Point shines in a Coca-Cola cocktail.

SQRRL: Warm Peanut Butter with a Syrupy Side

• Nose: Roasted nuts, caramel, ethanol
• Palate: Corn syrup, peanut butter, caramel
• Finish: Short, sweet corn, peanuts
• Alcohol content: 70 proof (35% ABV)
• How to drink: Cocktails

SQRRL entices with roasted nuts and caramel, a hint of alcohol lurking beneath the surface. The taste starts sweet with corn syrup, then transitions to peanut butter and familiar Jim Beam caramel notes. The finish is short and warm, leaving a sweet corn and peanut aftertaste with a touch of heat.

SQRRL prioritizes sweetness with corn syrup, while the peanut butter plays a supporting role. This, combined with the warmth, creates a unique experience compared to other peanut butter whiskeys.

Skatterbrain: Frappuccino in a Bottle (But Lighter on Peanuts)

• Nose: Vanilla, coffee, chocolate, alcohol
• Palate: Vanilla, coffee, peanut butter, mocha
• Finish: Vanilla, cinnamon
• Alcohol content: 70 proof (35% ABV)
• How to drink: Rocks

Skatterbrain’s aroma is a dessert lover’s dream: vanilla, coffee, and chocolate, with a hint of alcohol that fades quickly. The taste, however, is less complex. It’s like a syrupy Starbucks Frappuccino, with vanilla, caramel, mocha, and coffee flavors taking center stage, while the peanuts play a shy role.

Despite the lack of peanut punch, the finish lingers pleasantly with vanilla and baking spice, along with a moderate warmth. Skatterbrain truly shines in cocktails, especially when paired with Coke or incorporated into a Peanut Butter and Jelly mix.

P’Nutty: Honey-Roasted Delight (Not a Peanut Butter Bomb)

• Nose: Candied peanuts, honey, alcohol
• Palate: Sugar, caramel, peanut butter
• Finish: Honey, peanuts
• Alcohol content: 70 proof (35% ABV)
• How to drink: Rocks, cocktails

P’Nutty’s aroma is a candied peanut dream, with a touch of honey and a whisper of alcohol. The texture is dense and satisfying on the palate. While sweetness reigns supreme (think sugar and caramel), roasted peanuts play a supportive role. The finish is moderately long, offering a gentle warmth that reminds you it’s whiskey after all.

Expect a lingering sweetness of honey and a hint of roasted peanuts. P’Nutty prioritizes honeyed sweetness, but the pleasant burn makes it a rewarding sipper neat or on the rocks.

Bird Dog: Unleashing the Power of Peanut Butter Whiskey

• Nose: Peanut butter, vanilla, caramel
• Palate: Peanut butter, caramel, vanilla
• Finish: Medium, peanut butter
• Alcohol content: 80 proof (40% ABV)
• How to drink: Rocks, cocktails

Bird Dog isn’t messing around. It packs a bolder, 80-proof punch compared to other flavored whiskeys, offering a fuller-bodied experience.

The aroma is all about peanuts upfront, with subtle hints of vanilla and caramel joining the party. A quick sniff reveals a touch of alcohol that fades fast. The taste lives up to the nose, exploding with rich peanut butter and caramel, perfectly balanced by vanilla. The finish lingers pleasantly with a warming sensation and a lingering roasted peanut aftertaste.

Bird Dog walks the walk – it delivers the promised peanut butter flavor profile without any weird extras. Plus, the higher proof adds a touch of creaminess and intensity, making it a standout among peanut butter whiskeys.

Skrewball: The Peanut Butter Pioneer Still Packs a Punch

• Nose: Peanut butter, chocolate, roasted nuts
• Palate: Peanut butter, vanilla, chocolate, roasted nuts
• Finish: Short, peanut
• Alcohol content: 70 proof (35% ABV)
• How to drink: Rocks

Skrewball, the trailblazer of peanut butter whiskey, continues to reign supreme! The aroma is a delightful mix of peanut butter, roasted nuts, and a hint of chocolate, setting the stage for a delicious experience. The taste lives up to the promise, delivering a rich peanut butter punch complemented by roasted nuts, vanilla, and a touch of chocolate. The finish is short and sweet, leaving a pleasant roasted peanut aftertaste without any unwanted harshness.

Skrewball is a dessert whiskey in a bottle. It stays true to its peanut butter essence from the first whiff to the last sip, with no off-putting flavors or alcohol burn to disrupt the party. Even if you typically favor bolder spirits, Skrewball’s quality might surprise you, like it did me.

It’s a perfect addition to your home bar, ideal for serving guests who appreciate smooth and sweet pours, or indulging in a delightful dessert whiskey treat.

How to Choose a Good Peanut Butter Whiskey

Choosing the Right Peanut Butter Whiskey

• Flavor: Seek an authentic peanut butter taste that complements the whiskey.
• Smoothness: Look for a whiskey that’s easy to drink, without harshness.
• Aroma: A good peanut butter whiskey should have a pleasing nose, capturing both peanut butter and whiskey elements.
• Ingredients: Opt for whiskeys using natural flavors, avoiding those with excessive artificial additives.
• Brand Reputation: Consider the feedback from whiskey enthusiasts and expert reviews.
• Value: Choose a whiskey that offers a balance of quality and cost.

Health Considerations

While peanut butter whiskey is not a healthy drink, moderate consumption can be part of a balanced lifestyle. Remember, it’s often high in sugar, which can contribute to hangovers.

Frequently Asked Questions

A short FAQ to address your doubts:

What is peanut butter whiskey?

Is a flavored whiskey that incorporates the taste of peanut butter into the spirit.

How is it made?

Typically made by infusing peanuts or peanut butter flavor into a base whiskey, such as bourbon.

What does it taste like?

It has a distinct flavor profile that combines the rich, nutty taste of peanut butter with the traditional characteristics of whiskey, such as caramel, vanilla, and sometimes hints of chocolate.

How to drink it?

It can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or used as an ingredient in various cocktails.

Can I mix it with other drinks?

Yes, it can be mixed with various mixers, such as cola, coffee, or cream-based liqueurs, to create unique and flavorful cocktails.

Are there any peanut butter whiskeys without artificial flavorings?

Yes, Skrewball uses natural peanuts for infusion, which you can tell when tasting.

Is it suitable for people with peanut allergies?

If you are allergic to peanuts, you better not try your luck and avoid this type of whiskey.

Where can I buy peanut butter whiskey?

It has become widely available, so expect to find it in liquor stores across the U.S.

If you are just as lazy as me and prefer it delivered at home look into totalwine.com and drizly.com