Skip to Content

Bulleit Rye vs Lot No. 40: Head to Head!

Discover the differences between Bulleit Rye vs Lot No. 40 in this head to head comparison and decide which Whiskey is better for You!

Bulleit Rye

NoseMint, cedar, vanilla, rye spice
PalateCaramel, spearmint, vanilla, rye spice
FinishRye spice, oak spice, old leather
Alcohol content90 proof (45% ABV)
How to drinkRocks, cocktails
Similar toMichter’s Rye, Stellum Rye

Most rye whiskeys in the market are “barely legal”; as they only carry around 51% in the mash while the Bulleit carries 95% so you get a more spicy flavor.

Nose has a soft minty note, followed by cedar wood, vanilla and rye spice.

Palate offers a blast of rye spiciness at first, followed by spearmint hints, caramel and a touch of vanilla.

The finish has a medium to long length, pleasantly warm, with more mint and a tad of charred oak.

Solid dram as there is nothing off-putting about it, just a good old classic rye whiskey.

Bulleit hits you with the rich spicy notes you expect to find in this type of whiskey, but overall this is a sweet and smooth whiskey and quite easy to sip.

If you feel it too spicy add large ice cubes avoiding dilution; that will make it easier to sip.

Where this whiskey shines is in cocktails as the rich spice presence will add a nice kick to your favorite mix.

Overall, Bulleit Rye is a solid option, it won’t blow you away with any memorable tasting note but makes a good alternative for those looking for a spicy whiskey to make cocktails.

The Bulleit works well with a dash of Coke and even when mixed with weird things like energy drinks making it quite versatile.

Bulleit Rye facts:

  • It does not carry an age statement but it is aged between five to six years in heavily charred, new American oak casks.
  • Earned the Double Gold and Gold Medals at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition.
  • This whiskey is not crafted by Bulleit as it’s sourced at MGP of Indiana where several other Rye Whiskeys are crafted (Templeton Rye, Whistlepig, Angel’s Envy).
  • The Bulleit brand is owned by London-based Diageo (Johnnie Walker).

Lot No. 40 Canadian Rye

NoseGrass, mint, clove, honey
PalateCaramel, vanilla, spice, mint, grass
FinishLong, spice, orange, rubber
Alcohol content86 proof (43% ABV)
How to drinkRocks, cocktails
Similar toCrown Royal, Alberta Premium

While the Bulleit is 95% rye the Lot No. 40 takes it one step further as it’s 100% rye.

The Lot No. 40 is one of the few whiskeys along Alberta Premium and the Whistlepig made from a mash entirely made from rye.

Rye provides a distinctive spicy touch that works incredibly well in cocktails particularly in Old Fashioneds.

In fact, I prefer using a Rye Whiskey over a Bourbon to make cocktails.

The nose hits with the grassy and minty notes typical of rye whiskey, along a bit of clove and honey.

On the palate, the Lot No. 40 has a medium body providing a decent mouthfeel. Flavor is smooth and sweet as it hits with a caramel/vanilla combo at first, followed by mint, cinnamon, cardamom and clove.

The finish lingers for longer than expected, with no warmth on the way down, with notes of orange, a bit of rye spice, oak spice and a bit of rubber.

The Lot No. 40 is a smooth and easy drinker, with no burn or off-putting notes. Drinks nicely by adding water, on the rocks, although I feel it lacks the rye spice punch and warmth to make tasty cocktails.

Lot No. 40 facts:

  • This whiskey is 100% rye (90% Canadian rye and 10% malted rye).
  • Distilled in a single 12,000 liter copper pot-still.
  • Does not provide an age statement but is aged for around 3 years.
  • Crafted at the Hiram Walker Distillery in Windsor, Ontario.
  • The Hiram Walker Distillery is owned by Paris-based Pernod Ricard who holds big household names such as Glenlivet.

Bulleit Rye vs Lot No. 40: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

Bulleit Rye$33
Lot No. 40$40

Bulleit Rye vs Lot No. 40: Which is better?

The Lot No. 40 for sipping the Bulleit for cocktails

WhiskeyBulleit RyeLot No. 40
  • If you are in the market looking for a sipper the Lot No. 40 makes a better deal as this in a smooth and easy drinker that you can down neat or over ice.
  • It doesn’t shock me or wow me but gets the job done by providing a competent sip.
  • If exclusively looking for a whiskey to make cocktails then the Bulleit Rye will provide you a better Old Fashioneds as this pour hits harder with the spice and the additional proof will add a nice kick.