Skip to Content

E.H. Taylor vs Henry McKenna: Which Wins?

Discover the differences between E.H. Taylor vs Henry McKenna in this in-depth comparison and decide which Bourbon is better for You!

E.H. Taylor Single Barrel

NoseCaramel charred oak, cinnamon
PalateVanilla, caramel, cinnamon, oak
FinishLong, caramel, vanilla, old leather, oak
Alcohol content100 proof (50% ABV)
How to drinkAdd water
Similar toStagg Jr, Elmer T. Lee

E.H. Taylor is crafted at the Buffalo Trace Distillery using the same mash as the Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare.

The difference lies in this release being bottled in bond and pulled from a single barrel.

On the nose you get caramel, charred oak and cinnamon at first, but as you let it breathe old leather and honey pop-up.

On the mouth, the Single Barrel has a buttery and smooth feel, providing vanilla and caramel followed by cinnamon and charred oak with very little spice.

The finish has lingering caramel and vanilla hints, with old leather and a tad of oak. Incredibly smooth as it has almost no warmth making it a tasty easy drinker.

The E.H. Taylor Single Barrel is a terrific well-rounded dram.

Full-bodied and sweet, with very little heat and spice and the right amount of oak. It has lingering tasty flavors making it remarkably good.

No need to drink water or ice as it goes down easy. A little too easy!!!

Unfortunately, this bourbon is not easy to find, but I have you covered with a list of the Best Single Barrel Whiskeys so you consider further options.

There are a few facts worth knowing about the E.H. Taylor Single Barrel:

  • Aged for 11 years and 7 months.
  • Gold Medal at the Los Angeles International Wine & Spirits Competition in 2012.
  • Earned a score of 97 points at the Ultimate Spirits Challenge in 2012; Pappy 23 YO scored 95.
  • Colonel E.H. Taylor is one of Bourbon’s founding fathers and was instrumental in passing the Bottled-In-Bond Act of 1897.

Henry McKenna 10 Year Bottled in Bond

NoseEthanol, vanilla, caramel, citrus, clove, nutmeg
PalateCaramel, brown sugar, vanilla, oak, baking spice
FinishCaramel, vanilla and oak
Alcohol content100 proof (50% ABV)
How to drinkAdd water
Similar toEagle Rare 10, Evan Williams BIB

Henry Mckenna is the only extra-aged, bottled-in-bond, single barrel bourbon in the market making it unique.

On the nose I get ethanol at first, followed by sweet notes of vanilla and caramel with a drizzle of clove and nutmeg.

On the palate it feels hot up-front but mellows out fast into a sweet taste rich in vanilla, caramel, brown sugar and a touch of menthol; very little oak for a 10 YO, though.

The finish has a decent length, with more ethanol but not unpleasant along rye spice, vanilla, caramel and just a tad of oak.

Henry McKenna 10 is bitey and boozy but not bad by any means. A drop of water tunes-down that warmth that is present from nose to finish making it more enjoyable.

It checks all the right boxes for those who want a tasty and rewarding bourbon and a great option when in the mood for a tasty cocktail, one of the best 10 year old bourbons.

There are a few facts worth knowing about the Henry McKenna 10:

  • This bourbon is bottled in bond: product of one distiller at one distillery during one distillation season.
  • Henry McKenna is the only extra-aged, bottled-in-bond, single barrel bourbon in the market making it unique.
  • Made from a mash bill comprised of 78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted barley.
  • Called “magnificent” by Jim Murray, author of the Whisky Bible.
  • Earned a score of 90-95 points from Wine Enthusiast.

E.H. Taylor vs Henry McKenna: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

E.H. Taylor Single Barrel$150
Henry McKenna Single Barrel$70

E.H. Taylor vs Henry McKenna: Which is better?

E.H. Taylor is supremely good

WhiskeyE.H. TaylorHenry McKenna
  • E.H. Taylor is incredibly rewarding, as it drinks smoother than its proof while proving depth and complexity and overall a great bourbon and my favorite Single Barrel; but it doesn’t come chap, though.
  • Henry McKenna is quite good, but hits with some warmth making it more punchy.
  • Add water to it, lessen the heat and grow accustomed to it and enjoy a bourbon that delivers great value for the money.