Skip to Content

Knappogue Castle 12 vs Redbreast 12: Which Wins?

Discover the differences between Knappogue Castle 12 vs Redbreast 12 in this in-depth comparison and decide which Irish Whiskey is better for You!

Knappogue Castle 12

NoseFruit, oak, vanilla, caramel
PalateFruit, vanilla, malt, oak
FinishOak, honey, oak spice
Alcohol content86 proof (43% ABV)
How to drinkAdd water
Similar toJameson

The Knappogue Castle is a triple-distilled Single Malt whiskey which is a bit uncommon for Irish Whiskey which is normally made by blending malt and grain.

Knappogue 12 (Review) is distilled in copper pot stills, aged in ex-bourbon barrels, and bottled according to the year of distillation.

The nose is light on fruity displaying notes of tangerine, apricot and cherry, followed by vanilla and caramel and just a whiff of oak.

On the palate, it provides a medium body and an overly smooth flavor rich in fruity notes of tangerine, lemon and apricot, along a nice hit of vanilla and a malty touch.

The finish lingers with a pleasing warming note to it, honey sweetness and just a light bitter note coming from the oak spice.

Adding water brings more malt and oak while tuning down the rich fruity notes.

Knappogue is a nice and easy drinker, quite smooth with just a bit of a bite on the finish to remind you that you are drinking whiskey.

It doesn’t reach the heights of a Single Malt Scotch from Speyside but way better than the average Irish Whiskey at a price that makes it appealing as it’s hard to find a good 12 year old single malt at this price.

There are a few facts worth knowing about the Knappogue:

  • Crafted by Castle Brands which is one of the very few independent distillers in Ireland.
  • The brand is named after the Knappogue Castle in County Clare, originally built by Clan MacNamara in 1467.
  • The castle was restored by American-born Mark Edwin Andrews and his wife back in the 60s.
  • Gold – Irish Whiskey Masters 2022 – The Spirits Business.

Redbreast 12

NoseVanilla, caramel, ginger, orange peel
PalateRipe fruit, citrus, sherry, baking spice, oak
FinishRipe fruit, citrus, sherry, baking spice, oak
Alcohol content80 proof (40% ABV)
How to drinkNeat or add water
Similar toGreen Spot, Redbreast 15

The Redbreast 12 is crafted by Jameson but don’t expect it to taste like it as this whiskey is supremely good as it goes toe to toe with some of the best Scotch whiskies.

The nose brings a rich vanilla note, followed by caramel, a touch of ginger and a tad of orange peel.

On the palate, the Redbreast feels remarkably creamy with a rich texture that invites you to chew it. Flavor brings ripe fruit up-front, followed by hints of citrus, sherry wine and a good hit of oak.

Finish is long, bringing pleasing heat, along baking spice and dried fruit.

It strikes a perfect combination between sweet and spicy notes in an incredibly creamy body.

This whiskey drinks nicely neat and doesn’t need neither water nor ice and much less chaser as it goes down dangerously easy.

My only complaint is the proof which I feel is missing a bit, but overall this one of the best Irish Whiskeys you can buy today!

The price tag seems a bit high but you won’t remember it after a few rounds.

There a few facts worth knowing about the Redbreast 12:

  • The Redbreast is made from malted and unmalted barley.
  • Triple-distilled in copper pot stills to later be aged for 12 years in ex-bourbon and ex-oloroso sherry wine casks.
  • 96 points from Whisky Advocate.
  • Double Gold Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition on four separate occasions.
  • “Irish Whiskey of the Year” at the Irish Whiskey Awards in 2013.

Knappogue Castle 12 vs Redbreast 12: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

Knappogue Castle 12$47
Redbreast 12$63

Knappogue Castle 12 vs Redbreast 12: Which is better?

The Redbreast is one the best Irish Whiskeys

WhiskeyKnappogue CastleRedbreast
  • Knappogue is quite good and way better than the average Irish Whiskey but the Redbreast is incredibly good and of the best Irish drams.
  • Tasty, smooth, velvety, zero burn and something you should be drinking.