Skip to Content

P’Nutty vs Sheep Dog: Head to Head!

Discover the differences between P’Nutty vs Sheep Dog in this in-depth comparison and decide which Peanut Butter Whiskey is better for You!

Shepherd’s P’Nutty Peanut Butter Whiskey

NoseCandied peanuts, honey, alcohol
PalateSugar, caramel, peanut butter
FinishHoney, peanuts
Alcohol content70 proof (35% ABV)
How to drinkRocks, cocktails
Similar toSkrewball

The nose hits with a rich candied peanuts aroma followed by a hint of honey and just a whiff of ethanol that fades away.

On the palate, the P’Nutty feels viscous providing a good mouthfeel. Flavor is mostly sugar and caramel with peanut playing a secondary role.

The finish is fairly long, with a bit of a burn on the way down to remind you that you are drinking whiskey, leaving a sweet aftertaste of honey and a touch of roasted peanuts.

Peanut butter is not the main flavor as you get more honey and caramel from it, yet offers a pleasing burn on the finish making it quite rewarding.

This is an easy drinker that can be enjoyed either neat or rocks.

In summary, this is a good flavored whiskey that drinks as such, although not as rich in peanut butter flavor but in honey and caramel.

There are a few facts worth knowing about P’Nutty:

  • Crafted at K.D. Distilling Co. located in Louisville, KY.

Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey

NoseCaramel, vanilla, peanut butter
PalateCorn syrup, caramel, peanut butter
FinishCaramel, peanut butter
Alcohol content70 proof (35% ABV)
How to drinkRocks
Similar toSkrewball, Skatterbrain

The nose hits with caramel at first, followed by hints of vanilla and peanut butter.

On the palate, the Sheep Dog feels thin lacking in body. The first sip is overly sweet, with a very high corn syrup note, followed by caramel and just a bit of peanut butter flavor.

The finish is short, with more sweetness to it and a whiff of peanut butter.

Sheep Dog is a little too sweet for my taste as it becomes cloying after a few sips.

It’s rich in corn syrup and caramel flavors but lacks the promised peanut flavored note.

This is something I don’t recommend drinking neat or rocks unless you are fond of sweet-bombs, but can work in some peanut butter whiskey cocktails.

There are a few facts worth knowing about Sheep Dog:

  • Crafted in Louisville, KY.
  • Distiller claims to be using natural ingredients to infuse the whiskey but that’s something I find hard to believe as it tastes completely unnatural.

What to P’Nutty and Sheep Dog have in common?

Both are made by the Sazerac Company

These brands are both crafted in Louisville and owned by the Sazerac Company (Buffalo Trace).

Are P’Nutty and Sheep Dog the same whiskey?

The have different tasting notes

Based on taste you can tell that these whiskeys have been made using a different recipe.

P’Nutty vs Sheep Dog: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

Sheep Dog$10375ml

P’Nutty vs Sheep Dog: Which is better?

P’Nutty smells and tastes better

WhiskeyP’NuttySheep Dog
  • P’Nutty is better than Sheep Dog from nose to finish providing a better experience.
  • The first drinks nicely, with a pleasing burn on the finish.
  • Not the richest in peanut butter flavor, though, as you get more honey and caramel but this makes a sweet easy drinker.
  • The Sheep Dog smells and tastes cheap, but its hard to beat price makes it a better option to make cocktails.

Learn more about this type of whiskey by reading my post: Discover the Top Peanut Butter Bourbon where I rank every bottle.