Last Updated on: 9th April 2024, 01:22 pm
J Highland
J Highland is a certified sommelier with 30 years in the liquor industry, owning a pub, a liquor store, and moonlighting as a spirits distiller.
Discover the differences between Bowmore 18 vs Highland Park 18 in this in-depth comparison and decide which Single Malt is better for You!
Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as a spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.
Written by: J Highland
Bowmore 18 vs Highland Park 18: Comparison
Bowmore 18: A refined and balanced Islay dram, Bowmore 18 offers a gentle peat presence intertwined with sherry, ripe fruit, and chocolate notes. Its finish is characterized by a blend of soft rubber, peat, and oak spice. While not as complex as some might seek, it’s a solid entry for those looking to explore a subtler side of Islay.
Highland Park 18: This whisky stands out for its complexity and rich profile, balancing smoke with sweet and spicy elements like citrus, cinnamon, and chocolate. Its long finish of oak spice and smoke further showcases its well-rounded character. Highland Park 18 is a testament to the distillery’s ability to harmonize bold peaty flavors with the smoother nuances typically found in Speyside expressions.
Verdict: Bowmore 18 is ideal for those appreciating a smoother, less peaty dram with sherry influences, making it approachable and enjoyable. On the other hand, Highland Park 18 appeals to those seeking a whisky with great complexity and a perfect balance of peat, sweetness, and spice, states whiskey expert Neil Coleman.
Related: Best 18-Year Single Malt Scotches
Bowmore 18: A Smooth Journey with Subtle Smoke
- Nose: Peat, sherry, orange, ripe fruit
- Palate: Red fruits, chocolate, tobacco, oak spice
- Finish: Rubber, peat, sherry, oak spice
- Alcohol content: 86 proof (43% ABV)
- How to drink: Add water
- Similar to: Bowmore 15
Bowmore 18 invites you on a smooth and approachable exploration of Islay whisky. Let’s delve into its unique taste profile:
The Nose: A gentle peaty whisper opens the curtains, followed by warm notes of sherry, orange zest, and ripe fruit. Breathe it in and discover a harmonious aroma.
The Palate: Imagine this – a silky, viscous texture coats your mouth, setting the stage for a dance of red fruits, chocolate, and tobacco. Oak spice adds a touch of complexity, while subtle smoke and salt linger in the background.
The Finish: The experience lingers with a decently long finish, featuring a soft rubbery note, light peat, sherry influence, and a touch of oak. While not overwhelmingly complex, it provides a balanced conclusion.
The Verdict: Bowmore 18 shines as a refined expression of Islay, showcasing a low level of peat and smoke. It’s an easy-drinking dram where sherry and peat influences find harmony.
A Note on Memory: While some might find the flavor profile subtle or lacking standout notes, it excels in delivering a pleasant and balanced experience.
For the Peaty & Sherry Enthusiast: If you enjoy moderately peaty whiskies with a touch of sherry, Bowmore 18 won’t disappoint.
Unlocking Hidden Depths: A few drops of water can unlock further liveliness and complexity, making the experience even more rewarding.
Remember, taste is subjective! While Bowmore 18 might not be for everyone, its smoothness, subtle smokiness, and sherry influence make it a solid choice for those seeking a pleasant and approachable Islay dram.
Highland Park 18: A Journey Through Smoke and Harmony
- Nose: Smoke, oak
- Palate: Citrus, cinnamon, chocolate, honey, smoke
- Finish: Long, oak spice, smoke, chocolate
- Alcohol content: 86 proof (43% ABV)
- How to drink: Add water
- Similar to: Highland Park 12
Uncork a bottle of Highland Park 18 and embark on a captivating sensory voyage. Let’s dissect its unique character:
The Nose: A dance of smoky peat and aged oak takes center stage, followed by a delightful floral flourish. Breathe it in deeply and savor the complexity.
The Palate: While the body might feel lighter than some, the flavor packs a punch! Imagine a symphony of citrusy brightness, warming cinnamon, rich chocolate, and sweet honey, all interwoven with a moderate smokiness that adds depth without being overwhelming.
The Finish: The experience culminates in a lingering interplay of bitter chocolate, gentle warmth, and spiced notes, leaving a balanced and intriguing conclusion.
The Verdict: While not vying for the top spot, Highland Park 18 undoubtedly deserves a place among the greats. It masterfully balances peat with other flavors, ensuring no element dominates.
More Than Just Smoke:
- Beyond Speyside’s boldness, beyond Islay’s intense smoke: This whisky occupies a captivating middle ground, offering a unique experience for both peaty and non-peaty enthusiasts.
- A Remarkable Sip, Reasonably Priced: While not the cheapest, its quality justifies the cost. Consider it an investment in a memorable tasting experience.
- A Must-Try, at Least Once: Indulge in this exceptional dram at least once to appreciate its craftsmanship and complexity.
Remember, taste is subjective! But for those seeking a balanced and engaging Scotch with a touch of peat, Highland Park 18 might just be your perfect dram.
Price comparison
Prices are approximate and stated in USD:
| Whisky | Price |
| Bowmore 18 | $155 |
| Highland Park 18 | $195 |