Skip to Content

Dewar’s 12 vs Dewar’s 15 vs Dewar’s 18: Which Wins?

Discover the differences between Dewar’s 12 vs Dewar’s 15 vs Dewar’s 18 in this comparison and decide which Whisky is better for You!

Dewar’s 12

dewars-12-scotch-whisky
  • Nose: Lime, orange, apricot, pear
  • Palate: Lime, orange, caramel, vanilla
  • Finish: Medium, oak spice, pepper
  • Alcohol content: 80 proof (40% ABV)
  • How to drink: Add water
  • Similar to: Dewar’s White Label

Taste:

The nose is quite citric as it hits with notes of lime and orange at first, followed by apricot and a bit of pear. There is a whiff of smoke but very light that might not even find.

Flavor brings more of the lime and orange note from the nose. Notes of caramel and vanilla come next, along a bit of cinnamon and pepper.

The finish is short-lived, with just a bit of warmth on the way down but nothing extreme, with a bit of oak spice, pepper and a very light smoky note.

Is it good?

This updated version of the Dewar’s 12 The Ancestor that was discontinued represents an improvement as it feels better balanced and more enjoyable.

It doesn’t shock or wow but drinks nicely neat (considering the price) while it gets better when adding a dash of water releasing a tad of caramel.

It’s also a step-up from the regular Dewar’s whose primary use is as a whisky to make cocktails.

Dewar’s 12 facts:

  • This is a blend of 40 single malt and grain whiskies.
  • Double barreled in first-fill American oak ex-bourbon barrels.

Dewar’s 15

dewars-15-the-monarch
  • Nose: Apple, honey, pear, caramel
  • Palate: Pear, honey, cinnamon, orange
  • Finish: Short, dry, fruity, honey
  • Alcohol content: 80 proof (40% ABV)
  • How to drink: Add water
  • Similar to: Glenfiddich 12

Taste:

The nose is light, with hints of apple and honey at first, followed by caramel and a bit of cinnamon. Just a tiny whiff of alcohol is perceptible.

On the palate, the Dewar’s 15 feels oily providing a good mouthfeel. First sip brings hints of pear, honey, apple, orange and a drizzle of cinnamon.

The finish is short-lived bringing fruity notes, orange, with a dry feel to it and very little warmth making an easy drinker.

Is it good?

The 15 YO is an improvement over other Dewar’s releases as it provides a good mouthfeel with an overall good taste, no harsh or off-putting notes and very little to no burn.

Do I recommend buying it? It might look affordable at a first but you can find similar or better tasting Scotch blends at this price range.

It tastes like the Monkey Shoulder making me prefer the Monkey Shoulder which is a bit more affordable and although is not a Single Malt it’s a blend of Single Malt Whiskies making a better deal.

For a bit less you can get the Aberfeldy 12 which is a Single Malt and the biggest source of malts in the Dewar’s blend as these are sister brands.

Dewar’s 15 facts:

  • This is a blended Scotch made from up to 40 different whiskies.
  • The whiskies are aged in either ex-bourbon or ex-sherry before being happily married in oak casks.

Dewar’s 18

Dewars-18-Scotch-Whisky
  • Nose: Fresh bread, cherries, orange, baking spice
  • Palate: Oak, sour apples, ripe fruit, peat
  • Finish: Short, smoke, oak spice
  • Alcohol content: 80 proof (40% ABV)
  • How to drink: Add water
  • Similar to: Chivas 18, JW 18

Taste:

The nose is amazing as it hits with a Christmas Cake scent that brings hints of fresh bread, cherries, orange and a drizzle of baking spice.

On the palate, the 18 YO provides a somewhat thin body. First sip fails to deliver the Christmas Cake of the nose as it provides a musty oak taste and sour apples up-front with a little of ripe fruit coming behind.

There is a faint touch of peat present in the taste; very subtle, though.

The finish is short-lived, with a tiny whiff of smoke to it and and oak spice bitterness.

Is it good?

Not terrible but NOT something I would recommend buying.

It kicks-off with a nice Christmas Cake scent that doesn’t follow through on the taste where you mostly get musty oak and sour apples.

The finish is quite short, with very little warmth, though, but completely unremarkable.

Looks affordable at first glance but you can definitely get much better Scotch whiskies under $50 in the United States such as the Glenlivet 14 or the Glenmorangie Lasanta that are far more robust yet smooth.

Dewar’s 18 facts:

  • This is a blend of single malt and grain whiskies coming from 5 different distilleries owned by Dewar’s.
  • Aged in American oak before being blended and refilled into an oak vat.

Dewar’s 12 vs 15 vs 18: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

WhiskyPrice
Dewar’s 12$24
Dewar’s 15$37
Dewar’s 18$49

Dewar’s 12 vs Dewar’s 15 vs Dewar’s 18: Which is better?

The 12 YO is the smartest buy

  • The 12 Year is a solid release, is not going to blow you away with memorable tasting notes yet provides a good experience with no let downs.
  • Attractively priced and superior to the traditional White Label making a good deal.
  • The 15 YO is good, but sits at a price range in which you can get better whiskies such as the Glenfiddich 12 or the Aberfeldy 12 that make better whiskies.
  • The 18 YO is simply not that good, TBH, not terrible, but falls apart after a great nose delivering a so-so taste and an unremarkable finish.
  • You have much better whiskies at that price range hence I don’t recommend it.