Skip to Content

Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Head to Head!

Discover the differences between Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye in this in-depth comparison and decide which Rye Whiskey is better for You!

Knob Creek Rye

knob-creek-rye
NoseCherry, rye spice, oak
PalateOak, cherry, tobacco
FinishCaramel, old leather, dried fruit
Alcohol content100 proof (50% ABV)
How to drinkRocks, cocktails
Similar toWoodford Rye, Jim Beam Rye

Knob Creek is a “barely legal” rye whiskey as it only has a bit over the minimum of this spicy grain to belong to this category.

This makes it taste like a spicy version of the regular Knob Creek Bourbon.

The nose brings the same cherry note as the regular Knob Creek along notes of rye spice and toasty oak.

On the palate you get some rye spiciness while the high corn content in the mash makes it sweet. It has a thick oily mouthfeel and a flavor rich in oak, cherries and nice caramel with little to no burn.

The finish is long and pleasantly warm, rich in cinnamon, brown sugar, dried fruit and a faint rubber note lurking in the back.

The Knob Creek achieves a decent balance of spice, wood and dark fruit. It drinks nicely straight out of the bottle, with a splash of water, or after letting it breathe for a few minutes as it seems to improve over time.

The thick creamy body gives additional points to this dram and the fact that it does not drink like a 100 proof bottle as it has very little burn.

Overall, the Knob Creek Rye makes a good option for those who want to enjoy a rye whiskey with moderate rye spice or a “ryed bourbon” as I would call it.

There are a few facts worth knowing about the Knob Creek Rye:

  • The contents in the mash are not disclosed but the rye content is just over the minimum of 51% required by law.
  • This whiskey is labeled as “Patiently Aged” which is the nice way of implying that it does not have an age statement.
  • Won “Best Rye Worldwide Whiskey” at the 2016 International Wine and Spirits Competition.
  • Knob Creek is one of the many brands crafted and owned by Jim Beam.

Old Forester 100 Proof Rye

old-forester-rye
NoseRye spice, spearmint, cinnamon
PalateRye spice, cinnamon, clove, vanilla, caramel
FinishMedium length, anise, clove, cinnamon
Alcohol content100 proof (50% ABV)
How to drinkRocks, cocktails
Similar toRittenhouse Rye, Wild Turkey Rye

I like the Old Forester 100 Rye as it carries 65% of rye in the mash providing a still moderate amount of rye while bottle at 100 proof (50% ABV) providing pleasant warmth to make the Old Fashioned more punchy.

The nose hits with rye spice at first, followed by spearmint and cinnamon.

It has a nice peppery bite at first, offering notes of cinnamon, clove and baking spices. There is vanilla and caramel sweetness coming behind the spice blast along a licorice note.

The finish is a bit sharp and fairly warm yet pleasant, rich in rye spice, oak and more cinnamon which is present from start to finish.

The Old Forester Rye has some complexity, along some nice punchy flavors. It’s a bit warm but a drop of water is enough to make it sweeter and easier to drink.

In summary, The Old Forester 100 Proof Rye offers good value for the money, this is a pour full of character, moderately spicy, fairly warm and fully flavored.

It makes a good pour for an experienced aficionado capable of handling some bold flavors.

This is one the best whiskeys for mixing and my favorite to make Manhattans and Old Fashioneds.

There are a few facts worth knowing about this whiskey:

  • Launched in 2019 with the first new mash bill in 150 years!
  • The mash is comprised of 65% rye, 20% malted barley, and 15% corn.
  • The Old Forester does not have an age statement.
  • Earned Gold at the 2020 International Wine & Spirits Competition.
  • Crafted at the Brown–Forman distillery in Shively, Kentucky.

Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

WhiskeyPrice
Knob Creek Rye$34
Old Forester 100 Proof Rye$29

Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Which is better?

The Old Forester Rye is a more rewarding sip

WhiskeyKnob Creek RyeOld Forester Rye
Nose
Body
Palate
Finish
Value
  • Personally, I find the Old Forester to be a better whiskey as the additional rye spice makes it more flavorful and sufficiently different from its bourbon siblings.
  • The Knob Creek is quite low in rye making it taste more like a spicy Knob Creek Straight Bourbon.
  • Both are bottled at a high proof that does not feel, although the Old Forester feels a tiny warmer but is not harsh. Quite the opposite as this makes it more satisfying.

Basil Hayden's Rye vs Knob Creek Rye: Which Whiskey Wins?

Saturday 1st of October 2022

[…] Old Forester Rye, Bulleit Rye […]

Discover the Best Old Forester Bourbon Whiskey! Which is right for you?

Wednesday 6th of July 2022

[…] Also read: Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Which is Better? […]

13 Best Cheap Rye Whiskeys 2022: Top Ryes to Buy Right Now!

Monday 13th of June 2022

[…] Also read: Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Which is Better? […]

Old Forester Rye vs Wild Turkey 101 Rye: Discover Which is Better!

Saturday 23rd of April 2022

[…] Also read: Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Which is Better? […]

Old Forester Rye vs Rittenhouse Rye: Which Whiskey Wins?

Friday 22nd of April 2022

[…] Also read: Knob Creek Rye vs Old Forester Rye: Which is Better? […]