Maker's Mark vs Old Elk: Bourbon Comparison

Last Updated on: 9th April 2024, 01:43 pm

J Highland

J Highland is a certified sommelier with 30 years in the liquor industry, owning a pub, a liquor store, and moonlighting as a spirits distiller.

Discover the differences between Maker’s Mark vs Old Elk in this in-depth comparison and decide which wheated bourbon is better for You!

Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as a spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.

Written by: J Highland

Maker’s Mark vs Old Elk: Comparison

Maker’s Mark: A welcoming bourbon with a nose of acetone giving way to vanilla and cherry, leading to a palate rich with vanilla, caramel, honey, and cherry. The finish is a blend of cherry, vanilla, and a hint of pepper. Best enjoyed with a splash of water.

Old Elk Bourbon: Begins with aromas of old leather and caramel, evolving into a palate layered with cocoa, honey, cinnamon, and vanilla. The finish resonates with cocoa, cinnamon, and oak spice. Best experienced with water or on the rocks.

The Verdict: “Maker’s Mark offers a smooth and sweet introduction to bourbon, ideal for those new to the spirit or seeking a gentle sip. It stands out for its accessibility and balanced flavor profile, making it a versatile choice for various occasions. Old Elk Bourbon, with its higher proof and unique flavor combination, provides a complex and earthy experience, appealing to those ready to explore deeper into the world of bourbon.”, states whiskey expert Neil Coleman.

Related: Maker’s Mark Top Alternatives

Maker’s Mark: A Sweet & Smooth Sip for Bourbon Beginners

Nose: Acetone, vanilla, cherry
Palate: Vanilla, caramel, cherry, honey
Finish: Medium, cherry, vanilla, pepper
Alcohol content: 90 proof (45% ABV)
How to drink: Add water
Similar to: Rebel Yell

Aromatic Allure:

Maker’s Mark opens with a curious note – some might say reminiscent of nail polish, others a touch of cherry. But don’t fret, as it soon evolves into a sweet symphony of vanilla and cherry, leaving a pleasant aroma hanging in the air.

Flavorful Journey:

On the palate, this bourbon invites you with familiar flavors of vanilla, caramel, and honey, each dancing playfully with hints of cherry. The mouthfeel is smooth and enjoyable, perfect for a relaxed sip.

Lingering Finish:

The finish is modestly long, leaving a trail of sweetness with a whisper of black pepper heat. Adding a drop of water unlocks a hidden Tootsie Pop-like character, further easing the spice and introducing a bready warmth.

Is It the One?

Maker’s Mark might not boast the most complex flavor profile, but that’s its charm. It’s free of any harsh notes, offering a balanced and satisfying body. This makes it an excellent choice for those new to the world of bourbon or spirits in general. Think of it as your friendly “everyday whisky,” perfect for casual sipping without demanding your full attention.

Beyond the Sip:

This Kentucky classic uses a unique mash bill of corn, wheat, and malted barley, aged to taste rather than time. And yes, that iconic red wax seal? Still hand-dipped for that touch of tradition. Owned by Beam Suntory, Maker’s Mark stands apart with its smooth character and approachable profile, making it a great starting point for your bourbon journey.

So, should you give it a try? If you’re seeking a sweet, smooth, and easy-drinking bourbon, Maker’s Mark might just become your new go-to. It’s a crowd-pleaser for a reason, offering a gateway to the exciting world of bourbon without any intimidation.

Remember: Taste is subjective, so give it a sip and see for yourself!

Old Elk Bourbon: A Review Worth Your Sip

Nose: Old leather, caramel, earth
Palate: Cocoa, honey, cinnamon, vanilla, earth
Finish: Cocoa, cinnamon, oak spice
Alcohol content: 92 proof (46% ABV)
How to drink: Add water, rocks
Similar to: Weller Special Reserve

First Impressions:

Old Elk opens with a whisper of warmth, but quickly settles into a welcoming aroma of aged leather, rich caramel, and a hint of earthy intrigue. On the palate, it boasts a satisfyingly viscous texture, coating your mouth with a sense of richness.

Flavor Journey:

The first sip offers a cozy warmth, free of harshness. Notes of cocoa powder, honey, and cinnamon dance with vanilla, while the earthy whisper from the nose returns. A touch of crisp cereal, a signature of wheated bourbons, adds a pleasant lightness.

Lingering Finish:

The medium-to-long finish warms gently, echoing the cocoa and cinnamon with a subtle kiss of oak spice. While not the smoothest bourbon on the shelf, Old Elk avoids harshness with a charm all its own.

Is It Right for You?

If you’re new to exploring bourbons, Old Elk offers a friendly introduction with its inviting flavors and approachable warmth. Adding a drop of water unveils even more caramel sweetness, making it an effortless sipper. The unique cocoa note sets it apart, making it a stepping stone before venturing into bolder territories.

Beyond the Sip:

Crafted with care, Old Elk uses a special slow-cut proofing process that takes time but rewards with a balanced, smooth character. Its mash bill features 51% corn, 45% wheat, and 4% malted barley, contributing to its unique profile. Notably, it took home a Gold Medal at the New York International Spirits Competition, a testament to its quality.

So, is Old Elk worth a try? If you’re seeking a welcoming and flavorful bourbon with a touch of intrigue, this one might just become your new go-to. Give it a sip and discover for yourself!