Skip to Content

Sheep Dog vs Skrewball: Which Wins?

Discover the differences between Sheep Dog vs Skrewball in this in-depth comparison and decide which Flavored Whiskey is better for You!

Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey

NoseCaramel, vanilla, peanut butter
PalateCorn syrup, caramel, peanut butter
FinishCaramel, peanut butter
Alcohol content70 proof (35% ABV)
How to drinkRocks
Similar toRam’s Point, Skatterbrain, P’Nutty

The nose hits with caramel at first, followed by hints of vanilla and peanut butter.

On the palate, the Sheep Dog feels thin lacking in body. The first sip is overly sweet, with a very high corn syrup note, followed by caramel and just a bit of peanut butter flavor.

The finish is short, with more sweetness to it and a whiff of peanut butter.

Sheep Dog is a little too sweet for my taste as it becomes cloying after a few sips.

It’s rich in corn syrup and caramel flavors but lacks the promised peanut flavored note.

This is something I don’t recommend drinking neat or rocks unless you are fond of sweet-bombs, but can work in some peanut butter whiskey cocktails.

There are a few facts worth knowing about Sheep Dog:

  • This whiskey is made by Sazerac Company (Buffalo Trace) in Louisville, KY.
  • They claim to be using natural ingredients to infuse the whiskey but that’s something I find hard to believe as it tastes completely unnatural.

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey

NosePeanut butter, chocolate, roasted nuts
PalatePeanut butter, vanilla, chocolate, roasted nuts
FinishShort, peanut
Alcohol content70 proof (35% ABV)
How to drinkCocktails
Similar toSkatterbrain, P’Nutty, FIreball, Ram’s Point

The nose is quite pleasant as it hits with peanut butter and roasted nuts along a touch of chocolate.

On the palate, Skewball provides a rich peanut butter flavor, with more roasted nuts to it, vanilla and chocolate.

The finish is short, with no burn, harsh or weird tasting notes leaving an aftertaste of roasted peanuts.

Skrewball is dessert on glass, delivering the promise of a rich peanut butter flavor as you get it from nose to finish.

No weird notes or alcohol burn providing a good experience from nose to finish.

Must confess that this type of drinks are not my jam as I prefer smoky Scotch and other more challenging spirits but this thing is surprisingly good.

It’s reasonably sweet and something I could sip on the rocks or mix in cocktails such as the Peanut Butter Whiskey Milkshake.

There are a few facts worth knowing about Skrewball:

  • The recipe was formulated by Brittany Yeng who has a graduate degree in chemistry.
  • The project was self-funded by the Yengs.
  • Skrewball is made using real peanuts.
  • The source of the whiskey base is undisclosed.

Sheep Dog vs Skrewball: Price Comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

Flavored WhiskeyPriceSize
Sheep Dog$10375ml

Sheep Dog vs Skrewball: Which is better?

Skrewball delivers a better experience

WhiskeySheep DogSkrewball
  • Skrewball is pricier than Sheep Dog but well worth the upcharge as it tastes way better.
  • It delivers the promise of a peanut butter flavor while tasting natural with no funky notes to it.
  • It drinks quite nicely over ice or in cocktails providing good value.
  • The Sheep Dog smells and tastes like cheap whiskey infused with weird and super sweet flavors that promise a nasty hangover.

Learn more about this type of whiskey by reading my post: Discover the Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Brand where I rank every bottle.