Skip to Content

Jack Daniel’s vs TINCUP American Whiskey: Head to Head!

Discover the differences between Jack Daniel’s vs TINCUP American Whiskey in this in-depth comparison and decide which whiskey is better for You!

Jack Daniel’s No. 7

jack-daniels-7
NoseBanana, oak, wood polish
PalateCaramel, banana, oak char
FinishCitrus, black pepper, oak spice
Alcohol content80 proof (40% ABV)
How to drinkCoke
Similar toBlack Velvet, Woodford Reserve

The nose brings a plastic banana note, with hints of brown sugar, oak and just a bit of wood polish.

On the palate, Jack Daniel’s falls flat, with very little body as it lacks texture. Somewhat sweet up-front, with oak char bitterness coming behind overwhelming the sweetness as you keep drinking it.

The finish is almost non-existent, hot and peppery, with a hint of citrus and something that reminds me of Gorilla Glue.

I have fond memories as Jack Daniel’s was my first whiskey and something I enjoyed 20 years ago, but my taste has evolved greatly and now is something I would only drink if drowned in Coke.

It’s just too harsh to make a nice sipping whiskey although it gets better when adding rocks. Ice tunes down the heat and the pepper making it acceptable.

The best use you can make of the Jack No. 7 (Alternatives) is in cocktails, especially when mixed with Coke. In fact, I can’t think of something better except for those Caribbean rums to mix with Coke.

Drink Jack Daniel’s with Coke or ginger ale and you will be very happy with it… beyond that it serves no purpose as it’s just too harsh.

There are a few things worth knowing about Jack Daniel’s:

  • Jack Daniel’s is the best-selling whiskey across the globe with sales of over 100 million bottles per year.
  • JD is not a Bourbon, but a Tennessee Whiskey, made from 80% corn, 12% barley, and 8% rye.
  • Most distillers adhere to a set amount of years to declare a whiskey ready for bottling but Jack Daniel’s tasters decide when is ready based on color, aroma and flavor. 
  • Jack Daniel’s is filtered for up to 12 days through 10 feet (3 meters) of homemade sugar maple charcoal. This process removes some of the harshness from the spirit.

TINCUP American Whiskey

tincup-american-whiskey
NoseRye spice, ripe fruit, vanilla
PalateCorn, rye spice, apple, black pepper, ginger
FinishApple, baking spice
Alcohol content84 proof (42% ABV)
How to drinkRocks, cocktails
Similar toKnob Creek, Woodford Reserve, Bulleit

The nose hits you with with rye spice at first, followed by hints of ripe fruit and vanilla. A floral nose and quite pleasant.

On the palate, there is a flavor of sweet corn providing initial sweetness, that moves into gentle rye spice, baked apple, black pepper and a touch of ginger.

The finish has a decent length, neither short nor long but satisfying, with a bit of pleasant warmth to it, leaving an aftertaste of baked apple and baking spice.

Adding water releases a tad of caramel making it sweeter.

TINCUP Whiskey (Review) has a decent amount of complexity making a good mid-level whiskey that works well both in cocktails and by itself.

A great starting point if you want to get into bourbons high in rye before tackling rye whiskey brands.

Yet to try it in an Old Fashioned but the spicy notes promise to deliver a tasty cocktail.

The bottle comes with a miniature tin cup on top that can be used as a shooter making a nice little token.

There are a few facts worth knowing about TINCUP:

  • Made from a mash 64% corn, 32% rye and 4% malted barley.
  • Aged in new, charred American oak for 4-5 years.
  • TINCUP is made by MGP in Indiana and later shipped to Colorado where it is cut with Rocky Mountain snowmelt.
  • Founded by Jess Graber who was been distilling whiskey for 50 years.
  • The company is owned by Proximo Spirits, a subsidiary of Mexico’s Cuervo Tequila.

Jack Daniel’s vs TINCUP American Whiskey: Price comparison

Prices are approximate and stated in USD:

WhiskeyPrice
Jack Daniel’s$26
TINCUP American Whiskey$30

Jack Daniel’s vs TINCUP American Whiskey: Which is better?

TINCUP is a better tasting whiskey than Jack

WhiskeyJack Daniel’sTINCUP
Nose
Body
Palate
Finish
Value
  • TINCUP is a nice high in rye whiskey that drinks nicely on its own or in cocktails providing good value for the money.
  • Nothing remarkable or outstanding about it, yet get the job done providing a nice experience.
  • Jack is just meant to be mixed with Coke as it is a terrible sipper.

Jack Daniel's vs Jim Beam Black Label Extra Aged: Which Whiskey Wins?

Monday 14th of November 2022

[…] Maker’s Mark, Tincup […]

Knob Creek vs TINCUP American Whiskey: Which Wins?

Wednesday 3rd of August 2022

[…] TINCUP has a decent amount of complexity making a good mid-level whiskey that works well both in cocktails and by itself. A great starting point if you want to get into bourbons high in rye before tackling rye whiskey. […]

TINCUP American Whiskey vs Bulleit Bourbon: Which Wins?

Friday 29th of July 2022

[…] TINCUP has a decent amount of complexity making a good mid-level whiskey that works well both in cocktails and by itself. A great starting point if you want to get into bourbons high in rye before tackling rye whiskey. […]

TINCUP American Whiskey vs Woodford Reserve; Which Wins?

Friday 29th of July 2022

[…] TINCUP has a respectable amount of complexity making a good mid-level whiskey that works well both in cocktails and by itself. A great starting point if you want to get into bourbons high in rye before tackling big rye whiskey brand names. […]