Longrow Peated vs Kilkerran 12: Scotch Comparison

Last Updated on: 9th April 2024, 01:24 am

J Highland

J Highland is a certified sommelier with 30 years in the liquor industry, owning a pub, a liquor store, and moonlighting as a spirits distiller.

Explore a head-to-head comparison between Longrow Peated and Kilkerran 12, uncover their distinctions, and make an informed decision on which Single Malt better aligns with your preferences!

Quick Note: Running a pub and liquor store provides me ample access to various spirits, in addition, I moonlight as a spirits distiller. I assess them using customer feedback, expert opinions and online research.

Written by: J Highland

Longrow Peated vs Kilkerran 12: Comparison

Longrow Peated: A bold peat aroma with sweet caramel and fruit undertones, offering a thick texture and a spicy oak finish. A touch of Islay in Campbeltown.

Kilkerran 12: Sweet marzipan and pineapple on the nose, with a luxurious, oily palate of vanilla, toffee, and subtle smoke. Long, warming finish. Exemplary balance.

Verdict: Longrow Peated and Kilkerran 12 both offer distinct approaches to Scotch whisky. Longrow Peated presents a peaty, complex experience reminiscent of Islay whiskies but with its unique Campbeltown character. Kilkerran 12, on the other hand, stands out for its exceptional balance of sweetness and smoke, showcasing the craftsmanship of Glengyle Distillery. Each whisky provides a rich, fulfilling experience, catering to different preferences, states whiskey expert Neil Coleman.

Related: Best Peaty Single Malts

Longrow Peated

Similar to: Ardbeg 10

Peaty Promise: The aroma of Longrow delivers a powerful punch of peat, undeniably present like a campfire on a cool evening. Beneath this initial layer, you’ll find hints of sweet caramel and ripe fruits, adding a layer of complexity. While not as intensely peaty as Laphroaig 10, it makes a bold statement.

Mouthfeel & Flavor: On the palate, Longrow offers a satisfyingly thick texture, coating your tongue like velvet. The initial flavors surprise you with caramel and red fruit, unexpected sweetness balanced by hints of vanilla and a refreshing touch of menthol. The peat presence remains subtle, playing a supporting role rather than dominating the show.

Lingering Finish: The finish hangs around for a decent amount of time, offering a warming combination of smoke, lingering fruit notes, and spicy oak. A late arrival of gentle heat reminds you of the spirit you’re enjoying.

Islay Influence?: This Campbeltown whisky aims to capture the essence of an Islay experience. While it succeeds in offering a peaty profile, it lacks the aggressive smokiness of Laphroaig 10 or Ardbeg 10. Comparing it to Highland Park 12 reveals similarities in the flavor profile, though Longrow comes at a higher price and lacks an age statement.

Overall Impression: Longrow delivers a warming and spicy finish, but it might not leave a lasting impact on some. Those seeking an intensely peaty dram might prefer traditional Islay whiskies. Others might find Springbank 10, crafted at the same distillery, to be a more compelling option.

Longrow facts:

This malt was formerly known as the Longrow C.V.
Lacks an age statement.
Aged in bourbon barrels.
Unfiltered & uncolored.
Crafted at the Springbank distillery in Campbeltown.

Kilkerran 12

Similar to: Springbank 10

Intriguing Aroma: Kilkerran 12 opens with a captivating aroma that is both sweet and intriguing. Imagine the sweet richness of marzipan intertwined with juicy pineapple, vanilla bean, and a hint of dates. A delicate wisp of smoke lingers in the background, adding a touch of mystery.

Oily & Delightful: On the palate, the whisky reveals a delightful oily mouthfeel, coating your tongue like velvet. It’s luxurious and inviting.

Balanced Flavors: The flavor profile showcases a beautiful balance between sweet and complex notes. Vanilla, toffee, and honey lead the way, joined by a refreshing touch of orange and a subtle hint of smoke. This combination creates a thoroughly enjoyable and engaging experience.

Warming Finish: The finish lingers pleasantly, offering a warming sensation and notes of honey, orange, ginger, and a touch of black pepper. It’s satisfying and complete.

Enhanced with Water: While delicious neat, adding a few drops of water can further unveil the complexity of this whisky. It brings out deeper toffee and oak notes, adding another layer of enjoyment.

Simple Yet Satisfying: The overall character of Kilkerran 12 is one of simplicity and quality. It delivers a robust flavor profile without any harshness or off-putting notes, making it an easy and enjoyable dram for both seasoned whisky enthusiasts and newcomers alike.

Highly Recommended: Included in my list of “best 12-year Scotch whiskies” list speaks volumes about its exceptional quality. From the intriguing aroma to the satisfying finish, Kilkerran 12 offers a consistently delightful experience that deserves high praise.

Kilkerran 12 facts:

Aged for 12 years, utilizing 70% bourbon and 30% sherry casks.
Free from artificial caramel coloring and not chill-filtered.
Crafted at the Glengyle Distillery, established in 1872, closed in 1925, and revived in 2004.
The name “Kilkerran” derives from the Scottish Gaelic “Cean loch cillie kiaran” meaning “Home of Saint Kieran,” one of the Irish Apostles.